SBI MLS Defender of the Year: Matt Besler

Photo by

While he might not have been as flashy and outspoken as teammate Aurelien Collin, or as physically imposing as San Jose’s Victor Bernardez, Sporting Kansas City Matt Besler made up for his low-key persona by simply being the best and most consistent defender on the stingiest defense in Major League Soccer.

Besler’s ability to read the game helped thwart countless opposing attacks, and his steady and poised presence helped provide the perfect complement to the volatile Collin on a Sporting KC back-line that allowed just 27 goals in 34 matches. It was Besler’s consistently high level of play throughout the season that made him our choice for SBI MLS Defender of the Year.

One of the best passing centerbacks in the league, Besler’s ability to connect the defense to the attack was another underrated element of Besler’s game, and surely a factor in Jurgen Klinsmann calling him in for a look this summer. While he didn’t score a goal this year, and produced two assists, Besler’s contributions to the Sporting KC offense went well beyond those modest statistics.

Besler started 30 of 34 matches for Sporting KC, and it was clear during the stretch of matches he missed with appendicitis how important he was to the KC defense. The team’s stunning 4-0 loss to the Philadelphia Union came with him on the sidelines, marking the only time all season Sporting KC allowed more than two goals.

Besler beat out a strong field of contenders for the honor. Here is a rundown of the runners-up:


The imposing San Jose centerback was a true force in the middle of San Jose’s defense when healthy, and an early-season knee injury might have been what ultimately kept him from being our pick for defender of the year. He started 24 matches for the Supporters Shield-winning Earthquakes, and impressed not only with his physical strength, but also with his technical quality.


One of the driving forces behind D.C. United’s late-season surge, MacDonald was one of the steadier centerbacks in the league in 2012. After a less than impressive 2011, MacDonald responded this season by putting together the kind of season D.C. United was hoping for when they made him one of the league’s highest-paid defenders last season. Dominant in the air, and one of the most physical defenders in the league, MacDonald started 33 of 34 matches and almost always delivered solid performances.


When it comes to leading by example, Vancouver Whitecaps defender Young-Pyo Lee did that better than anybody, showing true class and skill as arguably the best fullback in the league in 2012. The South Korean star had no trouble adjusting to the league’s physical style, and he was one of the key factors behind the strong start to the season enjoyed by the Vancouver defense.


There were plenty of other candidates for MLS Defender of the Year who deserved mention, from Aurelien Collin to Nat Borchers to Carlos Valdes and Arne Friedrich, but the four defenders listed above stood out as the best of the bunch. And none enjoyed as strong and complete a season as Besler.

What do you think of our selection? Which defender impressed you the most in 2012?

Share your thoughts below.

This entry was posted in Featured, MLS- Sporting Kansas City, SBI MLS Awards. Bookmark the permalink.

12 Responses to SBI MLS Defender of the Year: Matt Besler

  1. Turd Bradley says:


    Matt Besler is a good player do we want him on the field or on the bench in a World Cup? I am not sure but one thing is for sure I did bring Jonathan Bornstein to a WC. Which still to this day is the worst player to ever play in a WC.

    Turd Bradley

  2. bizzy says:

    I’ve been saying this for a while since the MLS All-star game. Matt Besler and the likes of Morrow and Beitsahour just to name a few on that roster need a closer look at for international duty

  3. JRP says:

    Not a Seattle fan. But with Seattle allowing the fewest goals of any team in the west, how do they not have a defender on here. I know there have been injuries and maybe that is the answer. But Seattle has a defense that is the envy of the west. This coming from an RSL fan. SJ has allowed too many goals to have a defender on this list.

    • Brian says:

      I think this has more to do with how amazing Alonso is. He just makes it so much easier for that back line. Plus with the addition of Gspurning (GK of the year imho) they haven’t been put to too much trouble. The Seattle candidate would have to be Parke and I don’t consider him to be the premier defender deserving of the award.

  4. Shane says:

    Whatever happened to Chad Marshall?

  5. Shane says:

    Young-pho Lee did adapt amazing well and quickly to his new strange league. What a professional. Glad you gave him a mention

  6. Gary Page says:

    He only played about 60% of the season, but I don’t think it’s a coincidence that the Galaxy defense went from being incredibly porous to stingy after Omar Gonzalez returned. Even with de la Garza out their back line is holding up well, much better than when Gonzalez was out. That should tell you something.

  7. Bobb says:

    Victor Bernardez

  8. Josh says:

    Well deserved, very under-the-radar player. Not the big imposing force, but just always seems to be in the right place. Good example of smarts being more important than physical talent. Good call Ives.

    Hopefully he earns another call-up rather than forcing Edu and Cameron to struggle at a position they don’t play.

  9. Pingback: Sporting KC's Besler named MLS Defender of the Year