Who makes your Americans Abroad Best XI?

AronJohannssonAZAlkmaar5 (Getty)


With foreign leagues around the world wrapping up their seasons ahead of the World Cup, we are coming to the end of another eventful campaign for Americans Abroad.

We saw Aron Johannsson turn into a goal-scoring machine at AZ Alkmaar, Tim Howard help lead Everton to a very impressive fifth-place finish in the English Premier League, and Tim Ream win Bolton Player of the Year honors for an excellent season in the English League Championship.

In my latest Goal.com piece, I named an Americans Abroad Best XI for the season that is wrapping up in Europe and Mexico. It wasn’t an easy team to select, with several players falling short despite having had good club seasons.

There is no denying that the level of high-caliber Americans Abroad talent has gone down with the returns of Michael Bradley and Clint Dempsey to MLS, but there is reason to feel optimistic about the future as a large crop of young Americans climb their way up the ranks at various European and Mexican clubs. Players like Paul Arriola, Sebastian Lletget, Joe Gyau, Cody Cropper and Will Packwood to name a few.

Give my Americans Abroad Best XI piece a read and let us know which players you feel should have made the cut. What American impressed you the most with their play in a foreign country this past season? Which player were you most surprised to see included?

Share your thoughts below.

This entry was posted in Americans Abroad, Featured. Bookmark the permalink.

77 Responses to Who makes your Americans Abroad Best XI?

  1. Mike says:

    I saw the AZ GAME yesterday. AJ got some good chances even though he did not score.

  2. Bach's Thumb says:

    Abroad Best XI?


    Williams for Holden if you don’t want an injured player.

    • Ralph says:

      This team crushes the MLS squad.

      • JC says:

        Really…. crushes them?? Looks close to me:

        Davis Donovan Zusi
        Bradley Beckerman
        Parky OG Besler Yedlin

        • Luke says:

          MLS wins this easy…even if 5 abroads came from there

        • Louis Z says:

          YA team is stacked, no question are better.

          Boyd/Green/Agudelo <— chose one

    • Josh D says:

      Sorry, but if this is based on this season, Jozy is benched for Boyd. Holden misses out to Williams.

      Mine based on last season, and playing them in their proper positions:


      Guzan had a stellar year, yes better than Howard’s. Williams had a better year than Jones. I tossed Arriola in there for his breakout season, though you could put Green based on his reputation-defining first season as a pro. Ream did well and so did Fiscal; Gooch made a late run. Chandler had a good season but was too hot and cold. Brooks and Jozy disappointed. Mix started the season iffy but has made a direct impact almost every game and did well at the end of his previous season (which ended while the rest started).

      • Brian says:

        I have to respectfully disagree about Howard and Guzan. The statistics show that Howrad had arguably his best season, and while he certainly had a better defense than AV, his save percentage etc… is higer than Guzan’s

        • Josh D says:

          I’m just going by gut here. Howard still seems to lose a bit of focus with consequences. Guzan seems ready all 90. But that may be because of his defense.

          • away goals says:

            The gut tends to have a selective memory.

            Statistics are a useful countermeasure.

            • Paul says:

              Stats can be misleading. With a stronger defense and stronger team in general, you can frustrate opponents into trying shots they know are lower percentage takes. Keepers love games like that.

              Guzan rolled from one desperate moment to the next – a lot of broken defense, point-blank shots.

      • Josh D says:

        Forgot FJ. Toss him at LB.

        • Paul says:

          It’s hard to think of Johnson, Jones and Brooks as playing overseas from their homeland.

          Okay, that ought to start something, lol.

      • Luke says:

        Romando > Guzan

    • Tony in Quakeland says:

      You not only leave Ream off, you move Cameron to a postion he didn’t play. And you do it to fit in Chandler who was good for about a month and half this year.

      And Holden? Really?

      • Bach's Thumb says:

        Wouldn’t be hurt switching Ream and Brooks. I operate by the theory that you want all your best players on the field. Chandler is a better right back than Cameron. Cameron is a heads-up player who understands defensive positioning, which makes him valuable for moving into the center back position as he’s done in the past.

        I added the caveat for Holden and Williams. I recognize that Holden is injured, but when healthy he’s easily on the list.

        • Jack says:

          This list is who had the best season not who you would put out there. It sucks but Holden didn’t play a single minute.

          • Bach's Thumb says:

            He played during the Gold Cup–quite well. That was less than a calendar year ago so I included it.

        • fifawitz1313 says:

          OMG! IN WHAT WORLD IS CHANDLER A BETTER RB THAN CAMERON?!?!? Can someone please explain this anomaly of an opinion shared by so many on here? This line of dialogue is driving me nuts! Cameron plays RB in a better league, on a better team, and starts there for our national team. Have you seen Chandler play this season? He has been burned, benched, injured, and for a short stint effective there for Nurnberg (a team that just got relegated with a -33 goal differential, the worst in the Bundasliga). I get that we are desperate and so many want Cameron to slide in at CB (something that I would support), but to say that Chandler is some world beater who is better is non-sense. Stop the madness!

          • Bach's Thumb says:

            I hope you realize the ridiculousness of saying his team had a terrible goal differential and then also trying to attack him by saying he was out injured a huge portion of the season.

            You don’t think missing their best defender was… I don’t know a reason their defense fell apart?

            He was on multiple team of the week squads for the Bundesliga. He’s a top defender. It’s why Stuttgart are trying to pry him away.

            • Jack says:

              Cameron’s the better right back but it doesn’t mean Chandler is awful. Statistically they are pretty close all across the board. Cameron cuts out a lot more passes but that’s about it. Cameron’s also on the better club of coarse.

              • fifawitz1313 says:

                Fair, and maybe it came across like I was bashing Chandler. Not my real intent. I do not think he is awful and I really hope he earns a spot on the plane to Brazil. My point was that Cameron has been a consistently stronger player the entire season, and unless desperation causes us to move him to CB, he should be our starter.

          • Bach's Thumb says:

            To add to this:

            Schalke are reportedly pursuing Chandler as well. He’d be playing in the Champions League next season.

            • fifawitz1313 says:

              While he made a couple “teams of the week”, he showed little consistency. He was hot, he was cold. Unfortunately for him, right when it seemed like things were clicking he got injured. Saying he is going to Stuttgart is not exactly a ringing endorsement either. They only finished one position above the relegation playoff spot. I will happily eat crow if he goes to Schalke, but at this point in the year transfer rumors fly around with no legitimacy. Basing your opinion off of media speculation instead of actual on field results is crazy. Plus, let’s remember this conversation is about whether or not he is better than Cameron at RB. My points about Cameron above still stand. Better league, better team, starter on our national team. Not one of those facts can Chandler or you refute. Now, do I root against Chandler? Absolutely not! I pray that he becomes a RB beast and takes the job from Geoff. He has a much higher ceiling at the position. However, right now it is crazy to say Chandler is better, based on how this last season played out.

              • Jack says:

                Even if he did go to Schalke, it doesn’t mean he’d start.

              • Bac says:

                Fifa, did you watch him play? If so how many times? I’m not being sarcastic I’m genuinely curious because I don’t think many people who have commented about him have actually watched him this year, some have read post match reports.
                Even when I listened to another podcast yesterday all I heard was Honduras and airplanes….

          • Benny says:

            Mmmmmmm? In any world

    • RBNY says:

      Why Holden over Torres?

      • Nandez says:

        Cameron is a better CB than Rb.

      • Bach's Thumb says:

        Put Holden in there because of the Gold Cup–which I’m including as this past ‘season.’

        I added Williams at the bottom because I recognize not everybody would agree that counted.

    • Luke says:

      Johannsson should not be given a free pass to Brazil…Needs more seasoning on world stage.

  3. FRANK says:


    link to i.imgur.com

  4. Vic says:

    In your writing you have Sasha Klesjtan but in your lineup you don’t have him, you have Jermaine Jones instead.

  5. SPIT HOT FIRE says:

    Dy-lan Dy-lan Dy-lan Dy-lan

    Dy-lan Dy-lan Dy-lan Dy-lan

    Dy-lan Dy-lan

  6. Jack says:


    only difference really being Onyewu who really helped Sheffield Wednesday off the bottom of the table when he came in.

  7. USMNT Fan says:

    Based on the past season:


    • fifawitz1313 says:

      You can’t put Cameron at CB. He did not play one game there this season. Choose between Chandler and Cameron and make the right choice.

  8. bryan says:

    i think Ives got it spot on. hard to argue with any of those.

  9. Joe says:


    Hodor Hodor

    Hodor Hodor

  10. TheFrenchOne says:


  11. fifawitz1313 says:

    ——- Howard

    I tried to choose players based on the positions they actually played this season. Honestly, I would have left our LW blank considering there are not any players abroad really playing that position, but decided Torres was most deserving of a mention. I disagree with Ives that you can pick multiple players from the same position and have them on your best XI. Some of the players Ives listed weren’t even the best Americans Abroad at their own position. Plus, by listing actual positions it is more helpful determining a depth chart.

    • Jack says:

      I don’t believe Ream played a great deal at holding mid this season for Bolton. Certianly it was his play at left back and left center back is that he excelled into being Bolton’s POTY.

      • fifawitz1313 says:

        Jack, this could be my fault. I thought he played the majority of the season at DM & LB based on what I read here. I honestly didn’t watch him play this year. I had not read anything about him consistently being played at CB. I may be wrong here in which case put Ream where Fiscal is & add Jermaine Jones center.

    • Nandez says:

      I can’t believe he chose mix over torres. slap in the face

    • Jb says:

      How about Beasley for the LW. I believe he played wingback, close enough.

  12. ilikefreddyyesadu says:


  13. Scott e Dio93 says:

    Best XI based on this season performance:

    Boyd Johannsson

    Bedoya Jones Kljestan Corona

    Ream Brooks Gooch Cameron

    People forget: Ream played as leftback or centrelmidfielder, and Cameron was a rightback. Altidore had worst season his career, while Arriola and Will John I am not sure what position (midfieldo or forward) they played, and Kevin Hoyos start it good but back Argentina not playing time.

  14. FRANK says: